z

Young Writers Society



Rooftop

by Cold And Broken Halleluja


This is for clograbby's contest, Lost In The Atmosphere.

--

It hit me in the face -between the eyes, I might add. I could feel its stinging presence as it slid down my nose where it fell to its demise on my faded jeans. For a fleeting moment, I wished it was a bullet, putting an end to my misery instead of getting me wet. The sky growled deeply in the distance, probably sending down little soldiers to infiltrate the library through its cracked roof. Ms.Mcaffer was most likely catching them in foam coffee cups before they could harm her books. I laughed at the thought of the little invasion.

Static erupted out of the blue from the red radio beside me, and a unexpected gust of wind only added to the noise while causing it to tip precariously on its spot on the tin roof. After a few moments of watching the dog in our neighbor’s backyard pull the laundry down from the line, my music returned with crackling noises in the background –It wasn’t my fault the thing was as old as my grandmother. It began to play a soft tune that I especially loved. One that-

“You know that I hate that song.”

I grinned, and I was sure she doing the same standing in the yard down below. “Ladder’s on the other side,” I called back. I heard a shuffling noise through the grass below. Her movement on the ladder shook the branches of the oak tree that grew next to the side of the house. Some brown leaves fell, spiraling down into a puddle, no doubt. Fall was never beautiful here. It only meant soggy leaves and rain –lots of rain.

“Hey, Loser.” Her cheery voice pierced the macabre bleakness of the day –not to mention the reason she came.

“Afternoon, Freak.” She hit me in the arm for that one, and I couldn’t help but feel her freezing skin even through my sweater.

“Pretty boy,” She shot back, clearly flaunting the fact she could always manage to stand out. Though, wearing a t-shirt in the middle of November, I believe, was a little too extreme.

“Tomboy.” Truthfully, these were all terms of endearment, if you really look underneath the surface. Really deep.

She smiled when she realized I could keep up with our arguments a bit faster than when we’d first met. It soon faded away however and she sat next to me in silence. I was sure we were both feeling sick –with dread, regret, and anything else in between that would fit.

“Why aren’t you wearing shoes?” She said this in a casual, but puzzled tone.

I looked down at my feet, wriggling my toes defiantly with a goofy smile. I shrugged my shoulders, but I didn’t say anything. Honestly, it didn’t feel right to speak about the numbness I had been feeling ever since she told me. I think I just wanted to feel something again –So I had settled for the cold metal roof. Pointing out her lack of a jacket seemed like a good idea, but it had been too long since her question, and the silence had already settled back into place. I sighed loudly, the sound turning into a groan in my throat. Pulling my legs up close to my chest, I glared across my backyard while refusing to look at her.

“Wha…?” She didn’t even finish her thought before yelling, “I just wanted to come and say goodbye! You make everything so hard, Tucker!” She crossed her arms over her stained shirt.

“You make everything stupid, Lila,” I mumbled.

A leaf fell from the tree again, the soft click of its stem breaking the only sound that passed by our ears.

And then we couldn’t stop laughing.

It was as if we were seven years old again, laughing at the dumb comebacks we would come up with when we fought. She put her arm around my shoulder and I returned the gesture. I wanted to tell her I wasn’t going to let her go –that I didn’t care if her family had to go without her. The problem was –I did care.

Her laugh left mist in the air for a moment and I couldn’t help but look at her. I did care –because I knew no one could live without Lila.

Except for me –because I didn’t have a choice.

“You’re such a dork, Tuck.” Her green eyes sparkled like they always did when she smiled.

“Yeah,” I said with a grin that barely fit on my face. “But I’m your dork.”

Her sweet laugh died and her smile dwindled down to a straight line. She took a deep breath, filling her lungs with chilly air. “This sucks.” Funny –she hated it when people stated the obvious.

I nodded and pulled her close. I knew she would be leaving me in a couple hours, and tomorrow she would be on the other side of the country. With new friends. Without me. My hatred for our little town grew because it had made a special effort to reflect that day. The skies were as grey as my mood and the air as sharp as the insufferable circumstances.

The only source of color in that day was Lila’s hair. It was defiant like the rest of her –bright red, a beautiful watercolor on the most dreary of canvases.

It was sad, really, that we had once hated this town, so beautifully dull.

And now I had to hate it enough for the both of us.

--

Edit: I fixed some errors that managed to hide from me before.

;)


Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
402 Reviews


Points: 6517
Reviews: 402

Donate
Thu Oct 16, 2008 6:00 am
Clo wrote a review...



Hey Cold -

I'm sorry I took so long to get to reviewing this! Classes and work, you know? Life gets in the way of the good stuff. ;p

It hit me in the face -between the eyes, I might add.

I'm not sure what program you were using, but this dash seems sort of funny to meet. Very short. More like a hyphen. And there should be a space, "face - between"

I could feel its stinging presence as it slid down my nose where it fell to its demise on my faded jeans. For a fleeting moment, I wished it was a bullet, putting an end to my misery instead of getting me wet.

I think this is very great imagery for a raindrop, but it's not entirely clear that it IS a raindrop at first. Honestly, when I first read this I wasn't entirely sure what it was you were describing! All this needs to clear it up is just a descriptive word here or there - the only clue I have in this bit is that it was "wet".

The sky growled deeply in the distance, probably sending down little soldiers to infiltrate the library through its cracked roof. Ms.Mcaffer was most likely catching them in foam coffee cups before they could harm her books. I laughed at the thought of the little invasion.

Again, here. I think you've got a great description of rain going on here, but you're much too vague. Just add a slight it more descriptive language leaning toward what it actually is.

and a unexpected gust of wind only added

and an unexpected gust.

After a few moments of watching the dog in our neighbor’s backyard pull the laundry down from the line, my music returned with crackling noises in the background –It wasn’t my fault the thing was as old as my grandmother. It began to play a soft tune that I especially loved. One that-

the bolded "it" should not be capitalized - and again, the rule with the dash. And I must add, I really don't like the "one that-" at the end. I think you should start the thoughts, and then mentioned that they were interrupted, like "The images began to come into my mind, when they were interrupted" - something like that, your creative judgment choosing whatever.

Fall was never beautiful here.

I like that.

“Pretty boy,” She shot back, clearly flaunting the fact she could always manage to stand out. Though, wearing a t-shirt in the middle of November, I believe, was a little too extreme.

"Pretty boy," she shot back,
Don't capitalize the she

“Tomboy.” Truthfully, these were all terms of endearment, if you really look underneath the surface.[s] Really deep[/s].

Don't just make it a fragment like that. Get rid of it, or draw it out. "Though you might have to look rather deep to realize it", or something along those lines.

The problem was –I did care.

At this point in the story, I'm beginning to see you're a little too dash happy (*gasp* I'm a hypocrite! I'm always dash happy too, darn). Try to use them a little less. For instance, right here you can definitely get away with just a comma and still have the same effect.

Overall, a very cute story with some errors. I like the relationship between the two characters. I wish you drew it out more! Why did they hate the town? What memories do they have together? Readers demand the goods. :wink:

Congratulations, though, on placing.

PM me with any questions!

~ Clo




User avatar
25 Reviews


Points: 890
Reviews: 25

Donate
Wed Sep 10, 2008 8:23 pm



Thank you, Azila and CastlesInTheSky. I tend to read my stuff multiple times before I submit it, and yet all those little errors like to hide from me. :D

I loved the suggestions. Thanks!




User avatar
202 Reviews


Points: 890
Reviews: 202

Donate
Wed Sep 10, 2008 5:44 pm
CastlesInTheSky wrote a review...



Cold And Broken Halleluja wrote:This is for clograbby's contest, Lost In The Atmosphere.

--

It hit me in the face -between the eyes I might add.


Fanstastic beginning. SHould be a comma after "eyes".

I could feel its stinging presence as it slid down my nose where it fell to its demise onto my faded jeans.


I think there should be a comma after nose.

The sky growled deeply off in the distance, probably sending down little soldiers to infiltrate the library through its cracked roof.


The sky growled deeply off? Can the sky growl off? I think you just mean, the sky growled.

Ms.Mcaffer was probably catching them in foam coffee cups before they could harm her books. I laughed at the thought of the little invasion.


This is cute, but there's a repetition of probably. Find something else to replace it.

Static erupted out of the blue from the old red radio beside me, the sudden noise causing it to tip precariously on its spot on the roof.


I'm not sure noise would make a radio tip over. Then again, if you stated it was ancient and faulty, or something...

“You know I hate that song.”


Should be a comma after "know". Or maybe I'm wrong.

I grinned, and I’m sure she did the same down on the ground.


This sounds a bit off. Replace with , " I grinned, and I was sure she did the same, sitting down on the ground."


“Hey, Loser.”” Her cheery voice pierced the macabre bleakness of the day –not to mention the reason she came.



Macabre is a good word but you seem to have put multiple quotes after "Loser"

“Pretty boy.” She shot back, clearly enjoying standing out; though wearing a t-shirt in the middle of November, I believe, was a little too far.


This sentence is a bit off. let's break it down. "Pretty boy," she shot back, clearly enjoying the fact she stood out. Though, wearing a t-shirt in the middle of November, I believe, was a little too far.


“Tomboy.” Truthfully, these were all terms of endearment, if you really look underneath the surface. Really deep.


Ha! ^_^

I looked down at my feet, wriggling my toes defiantly with a goofy smile. I shrugged my shoulders, but I didn’t say anything. Honestly, it didn’t feel right to speak about the numbness I had been feeling ever since she told me. I think I just wanted to feel something again –So I had settled for the cold metal roof. Pointing out her lack of a jacket seemed like a good idea, but it had been too long since her question, and the silence had already settled back into place. I sighed loudly, the sound turning into a groan in my throat. Pulling my legs up close to my chest, I glared across my backyard while refusing to look at her.


This all has a very nice flow and is worded nicely.

A leaf fell from the tree again, the soft click of its stem breaking the only sound that passed by our ears.


Good!

And then we couldn’t stop laughing.


I think the conjunction at the start works here.

It was as if we were seven years old again, laughing at the dumb comebacks we would come up with when we fought. She put her arm around my shoulder and I returned the gesture. I wanted to tell her I wasn’t going to let her go –that I didn’t care if her family had to go without her. The problem was –I did care.


This is a good piece of background information and character developement.

The only source of color in that day was Lila’s hair. It was defiant like the rest of her –bright red, a beautiful watercolor on the most dreary of canvases.


This was beautiful.

And now I had to hate it enough for the both of us.

--


Awwwwww :( :( :( That was such a sad ending. It made me feel like crying.

This was a wonderful, emotional piece of work. Just watch out for tense problems and grammar.

PM me for anything.

Sarah




User avatar
721 Reviews


Points: 7241
Reviews: 721

Donate
Wed Sep 10, 2008 4:16 pm
Azila wrote a review...



It hit me in the face -between the eyes I might add.
Nice opening line! I think there should be a comma after "eyes," though.

I could feel its stinging presence as it slid down my nose where it fell to its demise onto my faded jeans.
I think that should be "on" rather than "onto."

Static erupted out of the blue from the old red radio beside me, the sudden noise causing it to tip precariously on its spot on the roof.
Do radios really tip over when noise starts to come out of them? That doesn't sound very realistic to me, but it might be true I guess... *shrug*

Fall was never beautiful here, anyway.
I suggest you delete "anyway." I think the line would be more powerful without it.

“Hey, Loser.””
Why are there two quotation marks in the end, there? :P

“Pretty boy.” She shot back, clearly enjoying standing out; though wearing a t-shirt in the middle of November, I believe, was a little too far.
That should be "Pretty boy," she shot back... (etc.)

She didn’t even finish her thought before yelling. “I just wanted to come and say goodbye! You make everything so hard, Tucker!”
The period after "yelling" should be a comma.

“You make everything stupid, Lila.” I mumbled.
The period after "Lila" should be a comma.

--------------------------------------

The first paragraph is just gorgeous. It sets the mood so, so well. And I love the metaphor about the soldiers in the library.

Also, nice introduction of Lila. You show their friendship quite well, from the way he can tell she's smiling when he is, to their play-fighting.

I really don't have much of anything bad to say about this piece, overall. You have lovely descriptions -- not to mention dialogue and characterization.

Let me know if I was unclear about anything.

Hope this helps,
~Azila~





“I am not worried, Harry," said Dumbledore, his voice a little stronger despite the freezing water. "I am with you.”
— Albus Dumbledore, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince